Rogers Park vs. Edgewater: Which Neighborhood is Right for Your Next Apartment?

When moving to a new neighborhood, especially in a big city like Chicago, the choices can feel endless. It is an important part of the process to consider what you want out of your neighborhood and community—do you value cool dining and going out spots? Frequent community events or close proximity to the lake? With some of the most beloved neighborhoods on the north side, this article will offer an up-close comparison of two of the best neighborhoods: Edgewater and Rogers Park. 

Location

Edgewater Location

Everyone is dying to live off the beautiful Lake Michigan, and if you move to Edgewater, you can. Located right off the water, the location is amazing for people who want to get outside every day they can. Especially with Hollywood and Foster Beach within walking distance, you will feel more blessed than ever to visit some of the best beaches in the city. 

Rogers Park Location

Rivaling Edgewater, a major draw of Rogers Park, is its beautiful lakefront location. The neighborhood is situated right along the shores of Lake Michigan, and there are many parks and beaches in the area where you can enjoy scenic views. Edgewater has larger beaches and quick access, but Rogers Park features smaller and less crowded experiences. 

Restaurants & Dining 

Edgewater Restaurants & Dining

If you walk down Broadway in Edgewater, you are in for quite a treat. With close neighbors like Uptown and Andersonville too, Edgewater has the best of all worlds. The biggest draw to living there is the close proximity to the famous Asia on Argyle. Featuring some of the best Asian food in the city- this location is a can’t-miss no matter where you live. And if it’s just steps outside your door, even better! Hop over to Sun Wah for some of the best Chinese in the city. Don’t forget to order their famous duck bao, and you can bring your own wine or beer! 

Rogers Park Restaurants & Dining

As for Rogers Park, if you are looking for authentic Indian and South Asian food, living near Little India is the only right answer. The area is filled with shops and foods of all sorts; they will have whatever you’re in the mood for! Little India features food from all different regions of the country as well as all over South Asia and is the biggest concentration of Indian and South Asian cuisine for miles. 

Shopping & Entertainment

Edgewater Shopping & Entertainment

If you value living near cool shops and things to do, Edgewater is the perfect location for this. Filled with shops, bars, and theatres, there is no shortage of things to do. In the summer, the plant stores, boutiques, and specialty shops come alive. A few of our Edgewater favorites are Green Element Resale, Broadway Antique Market, and the Gethsemane Garden Center. 

Rogers Park Shopping & Entertainment

Similar to Edgewater, Rogers Park offers an incredible shopping experience for all. From street clothing stores to traditional garb, the shopping on Devon Avenue compares to none. Whether you’re looking for bindis, bangles, Bollywood DVDs, and more – there is a spot on Devon Avenue for you. 

Housing & Affordability

Edgewater Housing & Affordability

Edgewater apartments are likely a bit higher in price compared to Rogers Park, but you pay for amenities and location just like anywhere else. High-rise condos are more common than single or multi-family apartment buildings. If you live on Sheridan Road, your neighbors will be on the other highrises. These pricy yet beautiful spots often offer amenities like fitness centers, rooftop decks, concierge services, and more. 

Rogers Park Housing & Affordability

Rogers Park offers a wide range of housing options, from historic homes to modern apartments. There are many beautiful old buildings in the neighborhood that have been lovingly restored, and these homes often feature unique architectural details and plenty of character. There are also tons of student housing, affordable studios, and one-bedroom apartments in Galore. 

Community

Edgewater Community

One of the most bustling neighborhoods on the north side, Edgewater is home to some of the best people and communities in the city. You’ll find that most of the neighborhood is young people, with a few retirement communities in between. This mix makes it the best middle ground for people looking for cool activities and shops and restaurants to go to, all while also worrying about a peaceful home and street.

Rogers Park Community

With a population that includes many different ethnic groups, Rogers Park is a melting pot of cultures. This fosters a beautiful community within the neighborhood, bringing together people from India, Pakistan, Mexico, Ethiopia, and many others. As a result, there are many opportunities to experience different cultures, try new foods, and get to know your neighbors. 

Final Thoughts

Depending on your priorities and your lifestyle, the pros and cons of each neighborhood might make this an easy or hard choice. If you find yourself drawn to a more hipster area with a strong community and affordable housing, Rogers Park might be for you. But if you prefer living in a neighborhood with more old-school charm and upscale dining, you might find yourself favoring Edgewater. Whatever you choose, there is no wrong answer! Both neighborhoods will welcome you home.